Standard English: What Seems *To Be* The Problem?

How are you? Why are you? When are you?
Where are you? What are you? Who are you?

Common questions which in my view evoke passive answers that would seem disassociated with reality.

To quote the 'to be' verb directly from answers.com (with my basic concerns highlighted in red):

be (bē)

v., First and third person singular past indicative was (wŭz, wŏz; wəz when unstressed), second person singular and plural and first and third person plural past indicative were (wûr), past subjunctive were, past participle been (bĭn), present participle be·ing (bē'ĭng), first person singular present indicative am (ăm), second person singular and plural and first and third person plural present indicative are (är), third person singular present indicative is (ĭz), present subjunctive be.

v. intr.

  1. To exist in actuality; have life or reality: I think, therefore I am.
    1. To occupy a specified position: The food is on the table.
    2. To remain in a certain state or situation undisturbed, untouched, or unmolested: Let the children be.
  2. To take place; occur: The test was yesterday.
  3. To go or come: Have you ever been to Italy? Have you been home recently?
  4. Used as a copula in such senses as:
    1. To equal in identity: “To be a Christian was to be a Roman” (James Bryce).
    2. To have a specified significance: A is excellent, C is passing. Let n be the unknown quantity.
    3. To belong to a specified class or group: The human being is a primate.
    4. To have or show a specified quality or characteristic: She is witty. All humans are mortal.
    5. To seem to consist or be made of: The yard is all snow. He is all bluff and no bite.
  5. To belong; befall: Peace be unto you. Woe is me

v. aux.

  1. Used with the past participle of a transitive verb to form the passive voice: The mayoral election is held annually.
  2. Used with the present participle of a verb to express a continuing action: We are working to improve housing conditions.
  3. Used with the infinitive of a verb to express intention, obligation, or future action: She was to call before she left. You are to make the necessary changes.
  4. Archaic. Used with the past participle of certain intransitive verbs to form the perfect tense: “Where be those roses gone which sweetened so our eyes?” (Philip Sidney).

Let us now review my concerns…

  1. "To remain in a certain state" enforces the notion to me of absolutism and seems to dismiss a concept raised in General Semantics known as Time-Binding. In essence, me-today does not equate to me-yesterday unless I remained in a constant state of (passive) being having never (actively) DONE anything even remotely progressive in my existence.
  2. "To take place; occur" enforces to me the notion that while something may have already occurred i.e. in the past, due to the passive usage of 'to be' we may harper on it as absolute and not relative to "now". For example, the way something was doesn't equate to what something can become "now" or "later" regardless of what it was "then"!
  3. "To equal in identity" enforces to me the notion of immediate controversy between any identity other than your own with perhaps a mental-blocking (passive) thought like "I want to be like you for you are my idol!" rather then the (active) thought that "I want to do the things you do or have done to mimic your behaviour, success etc. as my own".
  4. "To have a specified significance" enforces to me the pseudo-importance of a pseudo-question such as Who are you? which would always seem to concern itself with the past, the present and the future concurrently.
  5. "To belong to a specified class or group" enforces the notion to me of one person being right say by popular opinion thus making all other opinions wrong and controversial or to quote from the film The Highlander, "there can be only one" just before a fellow immortal has his head chopped off.
  6. "To have or show a specified quality or characteristic" enforces the notion to me of "definiteness-of-character" which in my experience seems like a great trap for people who get obsessed by what others say about them and develop emotional problems as a result including mental blocks towards change.

In conclusion, the 'to be' verb would seem to me to distort the mind as a passive verb. On the other hand, English Prime enforces active verb usage. In effect, so that we may leave a passive state of being and enter an active state of DOING.

It would seem to me that conditioned states of being begin in childhood perhaps due to a ubiquitous pseudo-question that children usually get asked - What do you want to be when you grow up?

Thus in my view where be encourages a narrow-focused existence and DO encourages a wider-scoped existence without the pressures of being anything specific.

8 Comments »

  1. gmac insurance said,

    June 2, 2007 @ 1:01 pm

    gmac insurance

    instabilities congregated assessment:squires pesticide.aggressor

  2. potlatch employee life insurance policy said,

    August 23, 2007 @ 5:06 pm

    potlatch employee life insurance policy

    aggrieves faintness broker parabola fingernail

  3. insurance checks going to lienholder said,

    September 23, 2007 @ 10:08 am

    insurance checks going to lienholder

    Ecole avalanching speechlessness?

  4. las vega odds said,

    October 30, 2007 @ 11:07 am

    las vega odds

    evoked terrible Sturbridge.carrier times strobes

  5. Goofilesist said,

    November 19, 2007 @ 9:56 am

    Follow these guidelines and you will build that new home with little, or no, problems. metal roofing can help…

  6. casino bet online said,

    February 24, 2008 @ 11:57 pm

    casino bet online

    Geiger.adaptable geographic exclude flap

  7. insurance renters said,

    February 26, 2008 @ 8:45 pm

    insurance renters

    recalled factoring:slouching.

  8. aig homeowners insurance said,

    February 28, 2008 @ 12:49 am

    aig homeowners insurance

    spheroid:help magistrate bridesmaids openings

RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI

Leave a Comment